110 research outputs found
Sustainability experiments in the agri-food system : uncovering the factors of new governance and collaboration success
In recent years, research, society and industry recognize the need to transform the agri-food system towards sustainability. Within this process, sustainability experiments play a crucial role in transforming the structure, culture and practices. In literature, much attention is given to new business models, even if the transformation of conventional firms toward sustainability may offer opportunities to accelerate the transformation. Further acceleration could be achieved through collaboration of multiple actors across the agri-food system, but this calls for a systems approach. Therefore, we developed and applied a new sustainability experiment systems approach (SESA) consisting of an analytical framework that allows a reflective evaluation and cross-case analysis of multi-actor governance networks based on business and learning evaluation criteria. We performed a cross-case analysis of four agri-food sustainability experiments in Flanders to test and validate SESA. Hereby, the key factors of the success of collaboration and its performance were identified at the beginning of a sustainability experiment. Some of the key factors identified were risk sharing and the drivers to participate. We are convinced that these results may be used as an analytical tool for researchers, a tool to support and design new initiatives for policymakers, and a reflective tool for participating actors
Fertilization: trade-offs between manure abatement and plant productivity
In 2005, 30% of the Flemish farms faced
a manure excess, while at aggregated level still 9.7% of
the emission rights were unused. This means that,
despite the various possibilities, Flemish farmers do not
succeed in an effective exchange of manure between
farms. In current paper is shown how inorganic
fertilizer use influences the use and exchange of organic
nitrogen. Because of the mutual interdependency
between organic and inorganic nitrogen emission rights
(or quota), inorganic nitrogen use limits the emission
rights for organic nitrogen. Utilisation of these emission
rights are analysed as a trade-offs choice between plant
productivity (use of inorganic nitrogen) and manure
disposal, as the major abatement alternative of manure
production. Farmers still prefer inorganic fertilizers
because of their effect on plant productivity and
income. However, by changing the quota rent of
organic nitrogen, the fertilization behaviour can be
influenced. A higher quota rent of organic nitrogen
would increase the use of manure. This trade-off
behaviour seriously influences effectiveness of policies.
When the objective is to lower the total nitrogen use, a
mere reduction of organic quota can partially be
counteracted by a higher inorganic nitrogen use. When
the objective is to better spread the manure, increasing
the quota rent for deficit farms will increase their
acceptance of manure
A farm level analysis of the relation between cap-reforms and local environmental legislations: how and in which extent Flemish dairy farmers can fill up extra milk quota
The agricultural policies shift gradually from EU-level organised market interventions to local organised environmental policies. This paper explores the growth possibilities of the Flemish dairy sector with the outlook of a quota abolishment as a case study of this policy shift. The dairy quota policy seems very restrictive for the highly profitable Flemish dairy sector, but the environmental restrictions from the manure regulation can limit the growth of the dairy sector as well. The paper uses a spatial multi-agent simulation model applied to a sample of 40.000 farms to estimate price development of emission rights and their possible impact on the growth of the dairy production. The results show that a higher milk production leads to higher prices for emission rights. However, the increased cost of manure emission rights is not expected to impede dairy farm growth because the current milk quota rent estimates go far beyond the cost of manure emission rights
A MAS model for optimizing the spatial aspects of livestock production and manure abatement
As a consequence of the EU Nitrates Directive many countries have developed policies to regulate manure production and manure emission on land. Farmers have three allocation options: spreading manure on own land, transporting manure to other farmers’ land and processing manure. To better understand the manure problem as an allocation problem a spatial mathematical programming multi-agent model has been developed. The model is applied for Flanders (Belgium), a highly concentrated livestock area. Using this model, policy alternatives and their cost efficiency can be evaluated. These simulations result in advice on location and type of manure processing and an indicator which creates transparency in the manure and processing market
Reflection on the development process of a sustainability assessment tool : learning from a Flemish case
Adoption of sustainability assessment tools in agricultural practice is often disappointing. One of the critical success factors for adoption is the tool development process. Because scientific attention to these development processes and insights about them are rather limited, we aimed to foster the scientific debate on this topic. This was done by reflecting on the development process of a Flemish sustainability assessment tool, MOTIFS. MOTIFS was developed with the aim of becoming widely adopted by farmers and farm advisors, but this result was not achieved. Our reflection process showed success factors favoring and barriers hindering tool adoption. These were grouped into three clusters of lessons learned for sound tool development: (1) institutional embeddedness, (2) ownership, and (3) tool functions. This clustering allowed us to formulate actions for researchers on the following aspects: (1) learning from stakeholders and end users, (2) providing coaching for appropriate tool use, and (3) structuring development of different tool types and exploring spin-offs from existing tools. We hope these normative results evoke other researchers to feed a debate on understanding tool development
- …